Homeowners insurance for 2026
Pick the insurer that fits your house and your life
There’s no single best homeowners insurance company. Different insurers charge different prices for the same house, and the right one depends on a few plain things about you.
Three questions sort most of it. Do you have a car to bundle? Do you want an app or a local agent? And does your house sit in a storm state, an older neighborhood or somewhere quiet?
Pick your card below. Then get at least three quotes for the same coverage, because a quote is the only place you’ll see your own price.
See which one fits youFacts checked on each company’s own site, plus J.D. Power, the Insurance Information Institute and state and federal consumer pages.
Which one fits you
- You also insure a car
Bundling is the discount these insurers lead with. Farmers says switch and save up to $1,232 when you bundle; Erie lists 15% to 25% and Amica up to 30%.
Farmers - You want it all in an app
Lemonade quotes, changes your policy and pays claims in its app. Policies start at $25 a month.
Lemonade - You want a local agent
State Farm, Erie and Allstate all sell through agents you can sit down with.
State Farm - You want the happiest customers
Amica ranked first in J.D. Power’s 2026 homeowners study and its 2026 claims study.
Amica - You live where storms hit
Kin has home pages for Florida, Louisiana, Texas and 11 more states. Read your wind deductible first.
Kin - Your house is older
Ask which policy form you’re getting. Some older homes are paid at actual cash value.
Older homes
The seven side by side
| Company | Best for | How you buy | Bundle discount it lists | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Farmers | Bundling home and auto | Online or through an agent | Up to $1,232 | Get a Farmers home quote |
Lemonade | An all-app policy | Online and in the app | Yes, amount not listed | Check Lemonade prices |
State Farm | A local agent | Agent or online quote | Yes, amount not listed | Read more |
Amica | Customer satisfaction | Online, by phone or in the app | Up to 30% | Read more |
Erie | An agent in 12 states and DC | Through a local agent | 15% to 25%, by state | Read more |
Allstate | An agent plus add-on coverage | Agent, with a mobile app | Yes, amount not listed | Read more |
Kin | Storm states | Online quote | Up to 10% off home | Read more |
Discounts and availability vary by state. A quote shows what you’d actually pay.
How we picked them
We don’t rank these seven. Each is here because it fits a certain kind of homeowner, and “best for” on this page means that and nothing more. A company made the list if it sells homeowners policies in more than one state, publishes its discounts and coverage online, and fits a clear type of buyer. Where J.D. Power measured a company in 2026, you’ll see the score.
We didn’t compare prices, because your price depends on your address. We also didn’t pull NAIC complaint data or AM Best financial ratings for these companies, so treat this as a place to start and check both before you buy. Step 6 below links to where.
Best homeowners insurance by situation
First-time buyers: line up a policy before closing
Homeowners insurance isn’t required by law. But if you have a mortgage, your lender almost certainly requires it.
So you need a policy ready before closing day.
Quote early. Kin takes up to 15% off the first year when you quote at least a week before your start date. Farmers, Allstate and Kin also have a discount for a new or recently bought home, so ask which ones you qualify for.
The policy is only one of the new bills. Our guide to hidden homeowner expenses covers the rest.
Bundling home and auto: ask for the combined price
Bundling is the discount these insurers lead with: switch and save up to $1,232 at Farmers, 15% to 25% at Erie depending on your state, up to 30% at Amica and up to 10% off the home policy at Kin. But always compare a bundle with your two best separate quotes. The cheapest pair isn’t always under one roof.
To see real numbers, run a Farmers home quote and a Farmers auto quote, then compare the pair to what you pay now. Our guide to shopping for car insurance covers the auto side.
Digital first: Lemonade, or Kin online
Never want to call anyone? Lemonade is built that way. The quote, policy changes and claims all happen in its app. Kin also quotes online in a few minutes. Check availability first, since neither sells in every state.
Want to see a price? Check Lemonade prices and see.
Older homes: check the policy form and the roof
Older homes can land on a different kind of policy. The Insurance Information Institute lists an HO-8 form for older homes. It usually pays actual cash value, which is replacement cost minus depreciation, and full replacement cost may not be available. Virginia’s Bureau of Insurance describes a market value form for older homes, which lets owners carry a lower limit.
Before you accept one, ask each insurer to quote a standard HO-3 too. Ask what it does about the roof. And ask for ordinance or law coverage, which pays extra when a repair has to meet today’s building codes. That’s a real issue in an older house. Virginia requires insurers to offer it, and elsewhere you should ask. Farmers also has a specialty home page for older, vacant and lower-value homes.
Storm states: read the wind deductible
In storm country the number that bites is often a separate wind, hail or hurricane deductible, not your regular one. Virginia’s Bureau of Insurance gives an example. On a home insured for $200,000, a 2% hurricane deductible means you pay the first $4,000 of damage. A 5% deductible means you pay the first $10,000.
Get that deductible in writing from every insurer. Discounts for strengthened homes can help. State Farm has wind mitigation discounts in some states, Allstate in Florida, and Kin for homes built to standards like IBHS FORTIFIED.
Cheapest: nobody can name it without your address
So who’s cheapest? We can’t tell you, and neither can anyone who hasn’t seen your house. What we can show is how much location matters. The NAIC’s 2022 average premium was $2,677 in Florida and $893 in Oregon.
To bring your own number down, raise the deductible. Only go as high as you could pay tomorrow from an emergency fund. Ask about protective device and roof discounts, and compare at least three quotes.
Claims experience: what J.D. Power measured
J.D. Power’s 2026 property claims study asked 5,093 homeowners who had filed a claim. Amica ranked first at 773, The Hartford second at 756 and Chubb third at 744. Its separate 2026 homeowners study scores the whole experience, price included, and ranked Amica first, Erie second and Chubb third.
Those are survey scores, not promises. We didn’t profile The Hartford or Chubb.
The seven companies, one by one
Farmers for bundling home and auto
Home and auto bundle

- Bundle home with another qualifying Farmers policy, such as auto, life or umbrella, and you can switch and save up to $1,232 when you bundle.
- Other discounts: three years claim free, a new home under 14 years old, protective devices, a connected home, UL-approved roofing and paying on time.
- Optional coverages include water backup and sump overflow, valuable items, identity fraud expense and matching of undamaged property.
- You can quote online or find an agent, and report a claim or check its status online.
- Farmers says new customers who switched their home and auto saved an average of $1,232 a year.*
Farmers fits you if you also have a car to insure and want one company for both, with an agent as a fallback. Start with the home quote, then add the auto quote to see the bundle.
The catch is that the $1,232 comes from customers who switched and saved. It isn’t what you’ll pay. And Farmers doesn’t list its states on that page, so your ZIP code tells you if it’s available.
*Farmers: based on average nationwide annual savings of new customers surveyed, excluding HI, SC and Farmers GroupSelect, from 9/1/24 to 8/31/25 who switched their home and auto insurance policies to Farmers branded policies, responded to the survey and realized savings. Potential savings vary by customer and may vary by state and product.
Lemonade for an all-app policy
All digital

- Policies start at $25 a month. Your rate depends on your state, your home’s age, building materials and what it would cost to rebuild.
- You quote, change your policy and file claims in the app. Once a claim is approved, Lemonade deposits the payment, minus your deductible, into your bank account.
- Discounts: bundling home with car, adding pet insurance, paying the year upfront, protective devices like smoke alarms and deadbolts, and a higher deductible.
- Lemonade says it’s rated A (Exceptional) for financial stability by Demotech, and it’s a certified B-Corp.
- It’s live in many states, including California, New York and Texas. In 29 states, its legal footer shows, home policies are written by Homesite Group companies instead of Lemonade Insurance Company.
Lemonade fits you if you’d rather never talk to anyone and you’re fine without a local agent.
Two catches. It isn’t in every state. And where Homesite writes the policy, look up the company actually on your policy and check its rating, not just Lemonade’s. Our Lemonade insurance review goes deeper.
State Farm for a local agent
Agent first

- You can find a local agent by ZIP code or start a quote online. The online quote takes about 10 minutes, and State Farm prefills details from public records.
- Discounts: bundling home with auto, renters, condo or life, home security devices, a claim free history (typically the past three to five years) and impact resistant roofing in some states.
- Wind mitigation discounts exist in some states, and wildfire mitigation discounts in California, Colorado and Oregon.
- Claims can be filed digitally. Flood insurance goes through the National Flood Insurance Program, and your agent can help you get it.
- It doesn’t list its states on that page and says details and discounts vary by state.
State Farm fits you if you want a person you can meet who can also write your auto policy. Its J.D. Power win in 2026 was for renters insurance, not homeowners, so ask your agent how they handle claims.
Amica for the highest satisfaction scores
Satisfaction leader

- J.D. Power ranked Amica highest in homeowners satisfaction in 2026 with 680, the second year in a row. Erie was second at 678 and Chubb third at 676.
- In J.D. Power’s 2026 property claims study, Amica also ranked first, at 773.
- Bundle auto with home, umbrella and life policies and the discount goes up to 30%.
- A dividend policy can return up to 20% of your premiums a year, Amica says.
- You can report and track claims online or in the Amica mobile app. Availability depends on your ZIP code.
Amica fits you if the best claims score we can measure matters more to you than a local office. The catch is that the dividend isn’t a discount you see on day one. Ask what the dividend policy costs up front, since the page doesn’t say.
Erie for an agent and guaranteed replacement cost
Agents in 12 states and DC

- Erie sells through local agents. It’s licensed in Washington, D.C. and 12 states: Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia and Wisconsin.
- Its base homeowners policy includes guaranteed replacement cost, in Erie’s own comparison with a typical competitor policy.
- Multi-policy discounts run 15% to 25%, depending on your state, when you insure auto and home with Erie.
- It also features fire, burglary alarm and sprinkler credits, and an advanced quote discount.
- J.D. Power ranked Erie second for homeowners satisfaction in 2026, at 678.
Erie fits you if you live in one of those states and want an agent. Outside them, skip it. The guaranteed replacement cost promise has footnotes, so ask your agent to walk through the conditions.
Allstate for an agent and add-on coverage
Agent plus app

- Allstate sells through agents and has a mobile app and an online claims center.
- Discounts: bundling home and auto, responsible payer, claim free when you switch, welcome and loyalty, new or recent homebuyer, early signing and protective devices.
- The early signing discount wants you to sign at least 7 days before your current policy expires.
- Florida homes with documented wind-damage features can get windstorm mitigation discounts.
- You can add coverage for jewelry, yard and garden, sports equipment and musical instruments.
Allstate fits you if you want an agent, plan to bundle and can quote a week early. Allstate says discounts aren’t available in every state and amounts vary, so its page can’t tell you your price.
Kin for storm states
Storm states

- Kin’s site has home insurance pages for 14 states: Alabama, Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas and Virginia.
- You enter your address for an online quote, and Kin says that typically takes a few minutes.
- Outside Florida and Louisiana, Kin’s base policy is House & Property insurance, which is similar to landlord coverage. If you live in the home, you add an owner-occupied endorsement to get coverage similar to an HO-3.
- Discounts: up to 10% off home and up to 20% off auto when you bundle, up to 15% off the first year for quoting a week early, and savings for homes built to wind, hail or fire-resistance standards like IBHS FORTIFIED.
Kin fits you if you live in one of those states, especially Florida or Louisiana, and want an online quote. Anywhere else, make sure the owner-occupied endorsement is on the quote, or you may be comparing a landlord-style policy to a standard one.
What homeowners insurance covers
A standard policy has six parts. Knowing them makes it easier to compare two quotes line by line. The limits below are Virginia’s Bureau of Insurance example of what’s typical, and your policy can differ.
| Part | What it pays for | Typical limit |
|---|---|---|
| Dwelling | Repairs to your house and attached structures after a covered event | The amount you choose |
| Other structures | A fence, shed or detached garage | 10% of the dwelling limit |
| Personal property | Your belongings if they’re stolen or damaged | 50% of the dwelling limit |
| Loss of use | Extra living costs while your home is unlivable | Up to 20% of the dwelling limit |
| Personal liability | Injury or damage you’re legally responsible for | Usually $100,000 per occurrence |
| Medical payments | Small medical bills for guests hurt on your property | Generally $1,000 per person |
HO-3 vs HO-5 vs older home forms
The form is the policy’s skeleton. The HO-3 is the most popular. It covers your house against every cause of loss except the ones it excludes, but it covers your belongings only for causes it names. The HO-5 covers both against everything not excluded. The extra premium for the broader kind is often relatively small, Virginia’s Bureau of Insurance notes, so ask for both prices.
| Form | Your house | Your belongings |
|---|---|---|
| HO-3 Special | All causes except those excluded | Named causes only |
| HO-5 Comprehensive | All causes except those excluded | All causes except those excluded |
| HO-8 older home | Usually actual cash value, which is replacement cost minus depreciation | Check the policy |
What it doesn’t cover
Flood and earthquake damage aren’t covered by a standard policy. Flood insurance is sold separately, including through the National Flood Insurance Program, and it usually has a 30 day waiting period before it starts. So buy it before storm season, not during it.
Neglect and wear and tear aren’t covered either, and neither are pest infestations or, in many cases, mold. A home warranty is a different product that covers appliances and systems when they wear out.
And how often does something go wrong? In 2023, 5.3% of insured homes had a claim. Wind and hail caused 42.5% of losses, water damage and freezing 22.6%, and fire and lightning 21.6%.
What drives the price
The average homeowners premium was $1,569 in 2022, up 11.2% from 2021. How close will you land? Probably not very. That’s NAIC data, and it’s the newest national figure the Insurance Information Institute publishes. Your own price can land far from it.
The big drivers are where the house is, what it would cost to rebuild, the age and condition of the roof, your claims history and your deductible. Location is the loudest. In 2022 the average was $2,677 in Florida, $2,603 in Louisiana and $2,397 in Texas, against $893 in Oregon, $937 in Utah and $948 in Nevada.
Rebuild cost isn’t market value. Land doesn’t burn down, so a house worth $500,000 on the market might cost more or less than that to rebuild.
That’s why there’s no flat price for a $500,000 house.
How to compare homeowners insurance quotes
- Pull out your current declarations page. It lists your dwelling limit, deductible and add-ons.
- Set the dwelling limit by what it costs to rebuild, not what the house would sell for. Carry at least 80% of replacement cost, Virginia’s Bureau of Insurance advises, because less than that can shrink even small claims.
- Get at least three quotes with the same limits and deductibles, so you’re comparing price and not coverage.
- Ask about the wind, hail or hurricane deductible, and which discounts apply. Insurers don’t always apply them on their own.
- Price the bundle. Ask each insurer what home and auto cost together, then compare it with your two best separate quotes.
- Look up the company that actually writes the policy. Check complaints in the NAIC’s Consumer Insurance Search and financial strength at AM Best.
- Switch cleanly. Start the new policy on the day the old one ends, and tell your mortgage servicer if you pay through escrow.
Homeowners insurance FAQ
There isn’t one. Amica ranked highest in J.D. Power’s 2026 homeowners satisfaction study. Farmers fits people who want to bundle with a car, and Lemonade fits people who want an all-app policy. Get at least three quotes for the same coverage before you choose.
The one that quotes early and lists a discount you qualify for. Farmers, Allstate and Kin each list a discount for a new or recently bought home, and Kin offers up to 15% off the first year when you quote at least a week before your start date. Your lender will almost certainly require a policy before closing.
There’s no flat number, because the price follows the cost to rebuild, your location and your claims history, not the sale price. For context, the average premium was $1,569 in 2022, from $2,677 in Florida to $893 in Oregon. Get three quotes for your address.
A standard policy has six parts: dwelling, other structures, personal property, loss of use, personal liability and medical payments to others. It pays for covered events like fire, wind, hail and theft, up to the limits you pick.
Both cover your house against every cause of loss except those excluded. The HO-3 covers your belongings only for named causes, while the HO-5 covers belongings against everything not excluded. The extra premium for the broader kind is often relatively small, so ask for both prices.
No. Standard policies exclude both. Flood insurance is sold separately, including through the National Flood Insurance Program, and it usually has a 30 day waiting period before it starts.
Often, yes. At Farmers you can switch and save up to $1,232 when you bundle; Erie offers 15% to 25% depending on your state, and Amica up to 30% across auto, home, umbrella and life. Compare the bundle with your two best separate quotes.
Enough to rebuild your home at today’s costs, which is different from its market value or your mortgage balance. A good rule is to carry at least 80% of replacement cost. Ask your insurer for a rebuild estimate.
The bottom line
Bottom line: get three quotes for the same coverage, and make one of them the company that matches your situation.
If you have a car, a Farmers home quote plus a Farmers auto quote shows you the bundle. If you want an app and no phone calls, check Lemonade prices. Everything else on this page helps you decide what to put on the quote form.
Sources (20)
We use primary sources: each company’s own product pages, J.D. Power’s press releases, the Insurance Information Institute, Virginia’s Bureau of Insurance and FEMA.
- Farmers. Property insurance coverage. farmers.com.
- Farmers. Homeowners insurance discounts. farmers.com.
- Farmers. Homeowners insurance coverages. farmers.com.
- Lemonade. Homeowners insurance. lemonade.com.
- State Farm. Homeowners insurance. statefarm.com.
- State Farm. Homeowners insurance discounts. statefarm.com.
- Amica. Home page. amica.com.
- Erie Insurance. Home insurance. erieinsurance.com.
- Erie Insurance. States of operation. erieinsurance.com.
- Allstate. Homeowners insurance. allstate.com.
- Allstate. Homeowners discounts. allstate.com.
- Kin Insurance. Homeowners insurance. kin.com.
- Kin Insurance. Home insurance discounts. kin.com.
- J.D. Power. 2026 U.S. Home Insurance Study (September 15, 2026). jdpower.com.
- J.D. Power. 2026 U.S. Property Claims Satisfaction Study (March 2026). jdpower.com.
- Insurance Information Institute. Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance. iii.org.
- Insurance Information Institute. Are there different types of policies?. iii.org.
- Virginia State Corporation Commission, Bureau of Insurance. Virginia Consumer’s Guide for Homeowners Insurance. scc.virginia.gov.
- FEMA FloodSmart. Flood insurance basics. floodsmart.gov.
- FEMA FloodSmart. Flood insurance 101. floodsmart.gov.



