Pet insurance can start at $7 a month for a cat and $10 for a dog. That’s the lowest price a company advertises, not what most people pay.
Lemonade’s dog owners average around $48 a month and its cat owners around $27. Across the industry, the average accident and illness policy runs about $70 a month for a dog and $36 for a cat, per the Insurance Information Institute, citing the North American Pet Health Insurance Association. What you’ll pay depends on your pet, where you live and how much of each vet bill you want covered.
Below you’ll see the price by insurer, what moves the number, and how to bring it down without gutting your coverage. Want local figures? There are pages for Virginia and Maryland.
Quick answer: three insurers, three kinds of owner

A Lemonade policy starts at $10 a month for a dog or a cat, and you file claims in its app.

You choose the deductible, the reimbursement and the annual limit. There’s also an accident-only tier if you want the lowest price.

MetLife has no upper age limit for enrollment, and its Family Plan puts up to three of your pets on one policy with a shared deductible.
Starting prices are the lowest each company advertises, on select plans. Your quote depends on your pet, your location and the options you pick.
How much is pet insurance for a dog?
Start with the floor. Lemonade starts at $10 a month and MetLife at $16 for a dog. Pets Best doesn’t publish a dog price, but its plans average less than $1 a day on new accident and illness policies for pets aged 0 to 10. That’s under roughly $30 a month.
Then look at real quotes. In Lemonade’s own cost article, a 4-year-old Goldendoodle in Chicago with a $250 deductible, 80% reimbursement and the maximum annual limit comes to $61 a month. Across all its dog owners the average is around $48. The industry average is about $70.
See the gap between $10 and $70? That is the plan you pick, plus the dog.
How much is cat insurance?
Cats cost less to insure than dogs, and MetLife’s starting prices show it: $7 for a cat against $16 for a dog.
The example from Lemonade is a 1-year-old short-haired cat in Danbury, Connecticut, with a $250 deductible, 80% reimbursement and no add-ons. That quote is $29 a month. Its average across all cat owners is around $27, and the industry average is about $36.
Bottom line: for a healthy cat, plan on $27 to $36 a month for accident and illness coverage, going by the two averages. The $7 and $10 starting prices are the stripped-down end.
Starting price vs what people pay, by insurer
| Insurer | Starts at | Average or typical | Get a quote |
|---|---|---|---|
| $10 a month, dog or cat | Around $48 for dogs and $27 for cats, per Lemonade | Get a quote | |
| Not published | Less than $1 a day on average for new accident and illness policies, pets aged 0 to 10 | Get a quote | |
| $16 for a dog, $7 for a cat | Not published | Get a quote |
Figures come from each company’s own pages. The three averages measure different things, so compare the starting prices with each other and the averages with each other.
Lemonade pet insurance cost
Lemonade is the easiest one to price, because it publishes the most. A policy starts at $10 a month. Owners average around $48 for dogs and $27 for cats, and the examples above ($61 for the Goldendoodle, $29 for the cat) show how fast a bigger dog and a big annual limit move the number.
You set the price with three dials. Reimbursement is 70%, 80% or 90%. The annual limit runs from $5,000 to $100,000. Deductibles start at $100. Lemonade says changing those could trim your premium by 10% to 15%, though you may be covered for less when a large bill arrives. Discounts include 10% for bundling, 5% for multiple pets and 5% for paying annually.
Add-ons cost extra. Wellness packages, dental illness, behavioral and end-of-life coverage are optional, and you won’t find their prices on those pages.
One thing to check before you pay: Lemonade’s pages show two different sets of waiting periods, so read the policy on your quote screen. It’s the pick if you want a low starting price and app-based claims. Want more say over the details? Look at Pets Best. Get your Lemonade quote takes a couple of minutes.
City by city, Lemonade’s averages run $35 to $50 a month across the Virginia and Maryland cities it lists. Those are on the Virginia and Maryland pages.
What changes your price
| What | How it moves the price |
|---|---|
| Dog or cat | Cats are usually cheaper to insure than dogs. |
| Breed | Some breeds cost more to care for, so they cost more to insure. |
| Age | Older pets need more care, and insurers can raise the premium as a pet ages. |
| Where you live | Pets Best prices on where you live and local vet costs. Lemonade’s Virginia averages run from $35 to $40 in one city to $45 to $50 in another. |
| Deductible | A higher deductible lowers the premium and raises what you pay out of pocket. |
| Reimbursement | A lower reimbursement percentage lowers the premium. So does a lower annual limit. |
| Add-ons | Wellness, routine care and exam fee coverage all add to the premium. Dropping them lowers it. |
From Lemonade’s cost article, Pets Best’s FAQ and its Maryland disclosure, and MetLife’s plan page.
How to pay less without losing the coverage
Raise the deductible first. It’s the dial that hurts least on a normal year, because you only feel it when you file a claim.
Enroll while your pet is young and healthy. Lemonade and Pets Best don’t cover pre-existing conditions, and MetLife defines them as anything your pet showed symptoms of, was diagnosed with or was treated for before you enrolled. A pet with nothing on file has nothing to exclude.
If you mainly want protection from the big surprise, look at accident only. Pets Best has that tier, and it’s typically the more affordable option. It won’t pay for illnesses, so a sick pet is on you.
Have more than one pet? MetLife’s Family Plan covers up to three on one policy with a shared deductible, and Lemonade takes 5% off for multiple pets.
What a claim costs you at each setting
Premium is only half the number. Say a $2,000 vet bill comes in on a plan with a $250 deductible and 80% reimbursement. If the deductible comes off first, you pay $250 plus 20% of the other $1,750, which is $600. If the percentage is applied first and the deductible comes off your reimbursement, you pay $650. Pets Best applies coinsurance first, so ask your insurer how it orders them.
That is an example, not a quote. It shows why a cheap premium with a big deductible and a low percentage can still leave you with a big bill.
Where to go next
If you want to compare more companies, the best pet insurance companies list covers the field. Have an older dog? You should read the best pet insurance for older dogs before you pick, since age changes both the price and what you can get.
Prices are the figures each company publishes and can change. Your quote is the number that counts.
How much is pet insurance FAQs
It starts at $7 a month for a cat and $10 to $16 for a dog on the cheapest plans. Lemonade says its customers average around $48 for dogs and $27 for cats, and the industry average is about $70 for dogs and $36 for cats.
MetLife starts at $7 a month for a cat and Lemonade at $10. Lemonade says its cat owners pay around $27 a month on average, and the industry average is about $36.
Starting prices are $10 a month at Lemonade and $16 at MetLife. Lemonade says its dog owners pay around $48 on average, and the industry average is about $70. A larger dog, an older dog and a higher annual limit all push the price up.
Lemonade says a policy for a dog or a cat starts at $10 a month. Its customers average around $48 for dogs and $27 for cats. Reimbursement, annual limit and deductible all change the quote.
Younger pets generally cost less to insure, because older pets need more care. Enrolling young also means fewer conditions to exclude as pre-existing.
Raise the deductible, pick a lower reimbursement percentage or annual limit, drop add-ons, or choose accident only. Each one lowers what you pay now and raises what you could owe on a big bill.



