A home equity loan hands you one lump sum at a fixed rate, with the same payment every month. A HELOC is a credit line you draw from as you need it, and the rate usually moves. Same house, same equity, very different bills.
So which one costs less? It depends on two things: whether rates go up, and whether you need all the money on day one.
Below is the same $60,000 run through both, three ways. The numbers make the choice pretty easy.
The quick answer
| Home equity loan | HELOC | |
|---|---|---|
| How you get the money | All at once, at closing | Draw what you need, when you need it |
| Rate | Usually fixed | Usually variable |
| Payment | Same every month | Changes with your balance and the rate |
| Interest is charged on | The whole loan from day one | Only what you’ve drawn |
| Best for | One big known cost, like paying off cards | Costs that come in stages, like a renovation |
| Risk | Your home secures it | Your home secures it |
That last row matters most. With either one, the CFPB points out you could lose your home if you can’t pay.
The same $60,000, both ways
To keep it fair, both get the same setup: $60,000, an 8.00% starting rate and 15 years to pay it off.
That 8.00% is just an example to run the math, not a quote. Your rate depends on your credit, your equity and the lender.
Take the full $60,000 on day one and the rate never moves? They cost the same: $573.39 a month and $43,210 in interest over 15 years.
So the product name doesn’t change the bill. What changes it is the rate moving, and how fast you draw the money.
| $60,000 example, 15 years | Monthly payment | Total interest | vs. fixed loan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Home equity loan, 8.00% fixed | $573.39 | $43,210 | Baseline |
| HELOC, rate stays at 8.00% | $573.39 | $43,210 | Same |
| HELOC, rate goes to 9.00% after year 2 | $573.39, then $604.81 | $48,111 | $4,901 more |
| HELOC, rate goes to 10.00% after year 2 | $573.39, then $637.09 | $53,148 | $9,938 more |
Example 1: the rate goes up
Say you take the whole $60,000 on a HELOC and the rate climbs two points after year 2, from 8.00% to 10.00%. Your payment jumps from $573.39 to $637.09.
That’s about $64 more a month for the next 13 years, and $9,938 more in interest than the fixed loan.
Even a one-point rise costs $4,901 more.
Rates can fall too, and then the HELOC wins. Nobody knows which way they’ll go.
The fixed loan is you paying for not having to care.
Bottom line: if you need all the money now and a payment jump would hurt your budget, the fixed loan is the safer pick.
Example 2: you draw in stages
Now say the $60,000 is for a kitchen and a roof. The contractor wants $20,000 to start, $20,000 at month six and the last $20,000 at month twelve.
With a home equity loan, you borrow all $60,000 on day one and pay interest on all of it while $40,000 sits in your checking account. Year-one interest: about $4,722, and your payments that year add up to $6,881.
With a HELOC, you only pay interest on what you’ve drawn. Paying interest only on $20,000 for six months and $40,000 for the next six comes to about $2,400 in year one, at the same 8.00%.
That’s $2,322 less interest in the first year, just from not borrowing money before you need it.
The catch?
Interest-only payments are small on purpose. Once the draw period ends and you start paying down the balance, the payment goes up, sometimes a lot. Know that number before you sign. Our guide on how to compare HELOC quotes shows where to find it on an offer.
Don’t skip the fees
The examples above leave fees out so the rate story is clear.
In real life, fees can flip the answer!
Ask every lender for the upfront cost in dollars, not just the APR. Some charge closing costs, some charge an origination fee as a percent of the line, and some charge an annual fee to keep a HELOC open.
Here’s how big that can get. Figure’s origination fee runs 0% to 4.99%. On a $60,000 line, the top of that range is $2,994, which would wipe out more than the year-one interest you saved in Example 2.
Where to check rates for each
Figure is a HELOC that behaves a lot like a fixed loan. You get the full line at closing, and the rate on that draw is fixed. Lines run $15,000 to $750,000, most states accept a 600 credit score (660 for investment properties), and funding can happen in as few as 5 days on loans under $400K. Checking your rate is a soft pull. Here’s our full Figure HELOC review.
If you want to draw in stages, the HELOC from Upstart Home Lending covers $26K to $250K with an easy, online application. See our Upstart Home Lending HELOC review for the details.
Which HELOC fits you?
Best for speedFunds in as few as 5 days
On loans under $400K- Lines $15K to $750K
- Soft credit check to see your rate
- 10, 15, 20 and 30 year terms
Best for credit from 600Scores as low as around 600
In some cases, and not in every state- Lines $26K to $250K
- 100% online application
- No annual fee or prepayment penalty
We may be paid when you use these links.
Want a true fixed-rate lump sum instead? Rocket Mortgage only does home equity loans, no HELOC. Our Rocket Mortgage home equity loan review covers what you need to qualify.
For more names side by side, see the best HELOC lenders. And if you’re not sure how much you can borrow yet, start with the home equity calculator.
Which one should you pick?
Go with a home equity loan if:
- You know the exact amount and need it all now, like paying off a card balance
- A payment that could rise would stress your budget
- You’d be tempted to keep drawing from an open line
Go with a HELOC if:
- The money goes out in stages, like a renovation or tuition
- You want a backup line you might not fully use
- You can handle the payment if rates go up
Ready to apply? Here’s how to get a HELOC step by step.
When neither one fits
Both need a monthly payment and decent credit.
If that’s the problem, look at HELOC alternatives.
A home equity investment pays you cash with no monthly payment, in exchange for a share of your home’s future value. It can cost more in the long run, so read the best home equity investment companies before you go that route.
If you’re 62 or older, a reverse mortgage is the other option. Here’s how a reverse mortgage compares to a HELOC.
HELOC vs home equity loan FAQ
Is a HELOC or a home equity loan better?
Neither is better across the board. A home equity loan is better when you need one lump sum and want a payment that never changes. A HELOC is better when you’ll spend the money in stages, because you only pay interest on what you’ve drawn.
Which one is cheaper?
At the same rate, taking the full amount at once, they cost the same. In our $60,000 example, a HELOC cost $9,938 more if its rate rose two points after year 2, and $2,322 less in year one if you drew the money in three stages. Fees can change the answer, so compare quotes in dollars.
Can you lose your home with either one?
Yes. Both are secured by your home, so if you stop paying, the lender can foreclose. Only borrow what you can repay even if your income drops for a while.
Can a HELOC have a fixed rate?
Some do. Figure fixes the rate on the full draw at closing. Many bank HELOCs are variable, so ask before you apply.



