6 Best Homeowners Insurance Companies of 2024

We look at J.D. Power, A.M. Best, and Consumer Reports ratings to determine the best homeowners insurance companies around.

Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure for more information.

Homeowners everywhere share a common desire: to secure their homes with the utmost assurance. It's a matter that involves not just monetary concerns but also peace of mind.

With myriad insurance providers vying for attention, it becomes crucial to discern the best from the rest. This guide delves deep into the best homeowner insurance companies, emphasizing their strengths, coverage options, and what sets them apart.

Criteria for the Best Homeowner Insurance Companies

Before venturing into specific companies, it's essential to understand the hallmarks of outstanding homeowner insurance firms:

  1. Robust Coverage Options: Be it protection against natural disasters, theft, or incidental damages, a superior insurance provider ensures a comprehensive range of coverage.
  2. Transparent Pricing: Premiums should be straightforward, with no hidden costs.
  3. Reputable Customer Service: An adept company offers prompt, helpful, and courteous support, ensuring claims are handled efficiently.

The Titans of Homeowner Insurance

The best home insurance companies offer a combination of affordable rates, comprehensive coverage, and excellent customer service. Here are a few of the top-rated home insurance companies in 2024:

Lemonade (Our Pick)

Lemonade Homeowner Insurance is a newer company that has quickly become a popular choice for homeowners. Lemonade offers a variety of features that appeal to tech-savvy consumers, such as a mobile app that makes it easy to get quotes, manage policies, and file claims. Lemonade also donates unused premiums to charity, which is a unique feature that sets it apart from other insurance companies.

Strengths:
  • Competitive rates: Lemonade offers competitively priced home insurance policies.
  • Convenient mobile app: Lemonade makes it easy to get quotes, manage policies, and file claims through its mobile app.
  • Charity donation program: Lemonade donates unused premiums to charity.
  • Tech-savvy features: Lemonade offers a number of tech-savvy features, such as chatbots and AI-powered claims processing.
Weaknesses:
  • Relatively short track record: Lemonade is a relatively new company, so it has a shorter track record than some of its competitors.
  • Some customer complaints about claims process: Some customers have reported problems with the Lemonade claims process.
  • Not as well-known as some competitors: Lemonade is not as well-known as some of its competitors, such as State Farm and Allstate.

Overall, Lemonade is a good option for homeowners who are looking for a competitively priced policy with convenient features and a commitment to social responsibility. However, it is important to be aware of the company's relatively short track record and some customer complaints about the claims process.

Homeowners Insurance by Lemonade – Quotes from $25/mo

Lemonade Insurance offers a new approach to renters, condo and home insurance. They even give back up to 40% of unclaimed money to the nonprofit of your choice.

Get a Quote Lemonade Review

USAA

USAA is a military-affiliated insurance company that offers some of the most competitive home insurance rates in the industry. USAA is also known for its excellent customer service and its willingness to work with customers to get their claims paid quickly and fairly.

  • Competitive rates: USAA is known for offering some of the most competitive home insurance rates in the industry.
  • Excellent customer service: USAA has a reputation for providing excellent customer service. Customers often report that USAA is easy to work with and that claims are processed quickly and fairly.
  • Military discounts: USAA offers a variety of discounts to military members, veterans, and their families.
  • Financial strength: USAA has a strong financial rating, which means that it is financially stable and able to pay claims.
Weaknesses:
  • Limited availability: USAA membership is only open to the military community and their families. This means that a significant portion of the population is not eligible for USAA home insurance.
  • No new policies in California: As of May 2023, USAA is no longer offering new homeowners insurance policies in California. This is due to a number of factors, including the state's high frequency of natural disasters.

Overall, USAA is a great option for military members, veterans, and their families. It offers competitive rates, excellent customer service, and a strong financial rating. However, it is important to be aware that USAA is not available to the general public.


Amica

Amica is another highly rated home insurance company. Amica is known for its financial strength, its commitment to customer service, and its wide range of coverage options. Amica also offers a variety of discounts, which can help customers save money on their premiums.

Strengths:
  • Strong financial ratings: Amica has strong financial ratings from all three major rating agencies. A.M. Best, a leading insurance rating agency, has assigned Amica Mutual Insurance Company a Financial Strength Rating of A+ (Superior). This rating reflects Amica's excellent financial condition and its ability to meet its policyholder obligations.
  • Commitment to customer service: Amica is committed to providing excellent customer service. Customers often report that Amica is easy to work with and that claims are processed quickly and fairly.
  • Variety of discounts: Amica offers a variety of discounts to policyholders, such as discounts for bundling home and auto insurance, having a security system, and being a claims-free policyholder.
Weaknesses:
  • Not available in all states: Amica homeowner insurance is not available in all states.
  • Limited coverage options for some perils: Amica's basic homeowner insurance policy does not cover flooding, earthquakes, or water damage from a plumbing backup or sump pump issue. These coverages must be added as endorsements.
  • Higher rates for older homes: Amica's rates for older homes can be higher than some other insurers.
  • Fewer discounts than some competitors: Amica offers a number of discounts for its home insurance policies, but some other companies offer a wider range of discounts.

Overall, Amica is a good option for homeowners who value customer service, financial strength, and comprehensive coverage. Amica's premiums are generally in the middle of the pack when compared to other major insurers, but some homeowners may find that they pay a bit more for Amica's quality coverage. Amica is best suited for homeowners who live in a state where Amica is available, have new homes, have good claims histories, and bundle their policies.


State Farm

State Farm is one of the largest home insurance companies in the United States. State Farm offers a wide range of coverage options and has a large network of local agents who can help customers with their insurance needs. State Farm is also known for its competitive rates and its quick claims processing.

Strengths:
  • Financial strength: State Farm has an A++ financial strength rating from AM Best, the highest possible rating. This means that State Farm is financially sound and able to meet its claims obligations.
  • Wide range of coverage options: State Farm offers a wide range of home insurance coverage options, including standard coverage, optional coverage, and specialty coverage. This allows homeowners to choose the coverage that best meets their needs.
  • Discounts: State Farm offers a variety of discounts on home insurance, including discounts for bundling policies, remaining claims-free, and having a home security system.
  • Local agents: State Farm has a network of local agents across the United States. This makes it easy for homeowners to find an agent who can help them with their insurance needs.
Weaknesses:
  • Fewer discounts than some competitors: State Farm offers a variety of discounts on home insurance, but some competitors offer more discounts.
  • New policies not being offered in California: As of May 2023, State Farm is not offering new homeowners insurance policies in California.
  • Some complaints about customer service: Some State Farm homeowners have complained about customer service issues, such as difficulty getting in touch with a representative or having claims processed slowly.

Overall, State Farm is a reputable home insurance company with a strong financial rating and a wide range of coverage options. However, homeowners should compare quotes from multiple companies before choosing a home insurance policy to ensure that they are getting the best price and coverage for their needs.


Allstate

Allstate is another major home insurance company that offers a variety of coverage options and competitive rates. Allstate is also known for its strong financial ratings and its commitment to customer service.

Strengths:
  • Strong financial stability: Allstate has an excellent financial strength rating from AM Best, which means that it is financially stable and able to pay claims.
  • Wide range of coverage options: Allstate offers a wide range of coverage options for homeowners, including standard coverage, optional coverage, and endorsements. This allows homeowners to customize their policies to meet their specific needs.
  • Cheaper than average: Allstate home insurance is cheaper than average, costing $1,369 per year. This is 13% less than the average cost of home insurance from the largest companies.
  • Good customer service: Allstate has a good reputation for customer service. It received a rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars in the J.D. Power 2023 U.S. Home Insurance Study.
  • Local agents: Allstate has a network of local agents who can help homeowners understand their coverage options and choose the right policy for their needs.
Weaknesses:
  • Higher premiums: Allstate's homeowner insurance premiums are typically higher than the national average.
  • More complaints: Allstate receives more complaints from homeowners than some other insurance companies.
  • Slower claims processing: Some homeowners have reported that Allstate's claims processing can be slower than other insurance companies.

Overall, Allstate is a reputable insurance company with a strong financial rating and a wide range of coverage options. However, its premiums are typically higher than the national average, and it receives more complaints than some other insurance companies. Homeowners should compare rates and coverage options from multiple insurance companies before choosing a policy.


Nationwide

Nationwide is a large home insurance company that offers a variety of coverage options and competitive rates. Nationwide is also known for its wide range of discounts and its commitment to sustainability.

Strengths:
  • Strong financial strength: Nationwide has a strong financial rating from AM Best, which means that it is well-positioned to pay out claims.
  • Wide range of coverage options: Nationwide offers a wide range of coverage options, including some that are not standard with other insurers, such as credit card coverage and Better Roof Replacement®.
  • Discounts for bundling and safety features: Nationwide offers a variety of discounts for bundling your homeowners insurance with other policies, such as auto insurance, and for installing safety features in your home.
  • Good customer service: Nationwide has a good reputation for customer service, with an average customer satisfaction rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars on J.D. Power.
Weaknesses:
  • Higher rates than some competitors: Nationwide's rates can be higher than some competitors, especially for customers with high-risk homes.
  • Some customers have reported difficulty filing claims: Some Nationwide customers have reported difficulty filing claims and getting their claims paid out in a timely manner.

Overall, Nationwide is a good choice for homeowner insurance, especially for customers who are looking for a wide range of coverage options and good customer service. However, it is important to compare rates with other insurers before making a decision.

How to Choose the Best Homeowners Insurance Policy

When seeking the best homeowners insurance companies, it's vital to first understand your coverage needs. Home insurance covers not just your dwelling but also personal belongings, liability, and additional living expenses. It's essential to evaluate:

  1. Dwelling Coverage Limit: The amount needed to repair or rebuild your home. Consider construction materials, square footage, and the rebuilding cost.
  2. Personal Property Coverage: For your belongings inside the home. For high value items, you may need extra coverage.
  3. Liability Coverage: Protects if someone is injured on your property. Consider higher limits if you have risks like swimming pools.
  4. Additional Living Expenses: Covers costs if you need to live elsewhere during home repairs.
  5. Additional Coverage: Depending on where you live, you might need flood coverage (consider the national flood insurance program) or earthquake insurance.

Speak to an insurance agent or use online resources like the Insurance Information Institute or the National Association of Insurance Commissioners to gather more insight. Many insurance companies of 2023 offer online quotes, making it easy to compare.


How to Buy Homeowners Insurance

  1. Research: Start with top-rated companies. Look at customer satisfaction, company's rating, and overall customer service.
  2. Get Multiple Quotes: Use home insurance quotes from various companies to compare coverage and costs. You can get a quote online from many insurers.
  3. Consider Discounts: Many companies offer bundling discounts. If you bundle auto and homeowners insurance, it might save you money.
  4. Evaluate the Deductible: A higher deductible usually means lower home insurance premiums, but ensure it's an amount you can afford if a claim arises.
  5. Read the Fine Print: Ensure you know what's covered and what’s not. For instance, most standard policies might not cover water damage from floods, requiring a separate policy.

Bundling Homeowners and Auto Insurance

Bundling your homeowners and auto insurance can provide significant savings. Most homeowners insurance companies offer a multi-policy discount if you purchase more than one type of coverage. Not only can this be a cost-effective approach, but having all your policies under one roof can simplify the claims process and paperwork.


How Expensive is Homeowner's Insurance

The average cost of homeowners insurance in the United States is $1,820 a year, or about $152 a month, according to NerdWallet's analysis. However, your actual rates may vary depending on a variety of factors, including:

  • The location of your home: Homeowners insurance rates are typically higher in areas that are prone to natural disasters, such as hurricanes, tornadoes, and earthquakes.
  • The age of your home: Older homes are often more expensive to insure because they may be more susceptible to damage and require more repairs.
  • The size and value of your home: Larger and more expensive homes typically have higher insurance rates.
  • The type of construction materials used to build your home: Homes built with more durable materials, such as brick or concrete, may have lower insurance rates.
  • Your claims history: If you have filed homeowners insurance claims in the past, your rates may be higher.
  • Your credit score: Homeowners insurance companies use your credit score to assess your risk as a policyholder. Those with good credit scores typically pay lower rates.

You can compare homeowners insurance quotes from multiple companies to find the best rate for your needs.

Tips for saving money on homeowners insurance

  • Shop around and compare quotes from multiple companies.
  • Bundle your homeowners and auto insurance policies.
  • Increase your deductible.
  • Make improvements to your home that can reduce the risk of damage, such as installing storm shutters or a new roof.
  • Take advantage of any discounts that your insurance company offers, such as discounts for security systems or claims-free years.

Keep in mind that the cheapest homeowners insurance policy is not always the best policy. It is important to choose a policy that provides the coverage you need at a price you can afford.


How to File a Homeowners Insurance Claim

If an unexpected event damages your property:

  1. Document Everything: Take photos of damaged belongings and property. This helps establish a record.
  2. Contact Your Insurer: Notify your homeowners insurance company as soon as possible. They will provide the next steps.
  3. File a Police Report: If the damage resulted from theft or vandalism, it's essential.
  4. Keep Receipts: If you need urgent or permanent repairs, keep all documentation. Most homeowners insurance policies cover such expenses.
  5. Work with the Adjuster: The insurance company will send an adjuster to evaluate the damage and determine the payout.
  6. Know Your Coverage: Understand what your policy covers. Whether you have actual cash value coverage or guaranteed replacement cost coverage can make a significant difference in your claim payout.

FAQs

1. What's the difference between actual cash value coverage and guaranteed replacement cost coverage? Actual cash value considers depreciation, paying only the depreciated value of damaged items. Guaranteed replacement cost covers the entire cost to replace items, irrespective of depreciation.

2. Does homeowners insurance cover damage from all natural disasters? No, certain natural disasters, like floods and earthquakes, are typically not covered by a standard homeowners insurance policy. You might need to purchase separate policies.

3. Why is bundling home and auto policies beneficial? Bundling often qualifies policyholders for discounts, leading to savings. It also streamlines the process for claims, payments, and any other service.

4. What factors influence my home insurance premiums? Several factors, including the dwelling's value, location, construction type, your claims history, and the coverage amount selected, can influence rates.

5. Can I change my homeowners policy after purchasing? Yes, if you find better coverage or rates with other home insurance companies or if your living situation changes, you can update or switch your policy.

Summary

Overall, all of the companies you mentioned are highly rated home insurance companies. The best company for you will depend on your individual needs and preferences. If you are a military member or veteran, USAA is a great option.

If you are looking for a company with a wide range of coverage options and competitive rates, Lemonade, State Farm or Allstate are good choices. If you are looking for a company with a strong commitment to customer service, Amica is a good option. And if you are looking for a company that is committed to sustainability, Nationwide is a good choice.

I recommend that you get quotes from multiple companies before making a decision. This will help you to compare rates and coverage options so that you can choose the best policy for your needs.

Homeowners Insurance by Lemonade – Quotes from $25/mo

Lemonade Insurance offers a new approach to renters, condo and home insurance. They even give back up to 40% of unclaimed money to the nonprofit of your choice.

Get a Quote Lemonade Review

About the author

Brian Meiggs
Hi, I'm Brian Meiggs! A personal finance expert, entrepreneur, and the founder of My Millennial Guide. My drive is to help others unlock the wealth of freedom and pave the path to financial success. With my bachelor's degree in finance, I help millennials follow the smart money in order to increase their earning potential and start building wealth for the future. I write regularly about side hustles, investing, and general personal finance topics aimed to help anyone earn more, pay off debt, and reach financial freedom. I have been quoted in major publications including Business Insider, Yahoo Finance, NASDAQ, Discover, GoDaddy, BiggerPockets, Fox News, Debt.com, Quick Sprout, Money Geek, MSN Money and many more!